Key Points
- The increase in interest rates affects the cost of capturing alpha in hedge funds.
- Higher interest rates reduce the alpha captured by investors.
- The alpha capture ratio measures the cost of alpha.
- Managers with higher equity betas experience a greater decline in alpha capture with rising interest rates.
- Different fee structures and risk-free rates impact the alpha capture rate.
- Investors should negotiate performance fee discounts and consider implementing a risk-free rate performance fee hurdle.
The rapid rise of the federal funds rate from almost 0% in 2022 to a 15-year high of 5.25% in July 2023 presents an opportunity for hedge funds’ expected returns and a silent increase in the price of alpha. However, given the trajectory of interest rates, the alpha captured by investors who invested with a good manager with an equity beta of 1 may have fallen by 36%.
To optimize the price paid for alpha, hedge fund investors can utilize the alpha capture ratio metric. This metric gauges the cost of alpha by comparing managers with different equity betas in various interest rate environments. The alpha capture ratio is calculated by dividing the net alpha by the gross alpha.
How Do Different Manager Risk Profiles Impact the Alpha Capture Ratio?
In an environment with a 6% equity risk premium, we can compare the performance of a Good Manager and a Bad Manager. The Good Manager achieves a gross alpha of 7%, while the Bad Manager achieves a gross alpha of 3%. The alpha capture rate for the Good Manager remains relatively high across different equity beta levels when the risk-free rate is 0%, but declines significantly as the risk-free rate rises to 5%. This trend highlights the impact of rising interest rates on the price of alpha, especially for managers with higher equity beta levels.
For the Bad Manager with an equity beta of 0.2, the alpha capture rate decreases from 54% to 19% as the gross alpha drops from 7% to 3%. This decline persists as the equity beta increases, emphasizing the importance of manager selection.
Alpha Capture with Different Fee Structures and Risk-Free Rates
The alpha capture rate varies based on the fee structure and the risk-free rate. A lower management fee and performance fee structure generally result in a higher alpha capture rate. However, the impact of reducing the management fee is more significant than reducing the performance fee, especially when the risk-free rate is higher. Investors may consider negotiating performance fee discounts or implementing a risk-free rate performance fee hurdle.
Overall, investors should be aware of the influence of rising interest rates and performance fees on alpha capture. To maximize alpha capture, they should engage with managers to negotiate performance fee discounts and consider implementing a risk-free rate performance fee hurdle.
Looking Ahead
In the current high interest rate environment, investors should prioritize negotiating a discount on performance fees rather than management fees. Implementing a risk-free rate performance fee hurdle can also be a valuable option. It is crucial for investors to consider the impact of the performance fee hurdle when evaluating a manager’s future performance. With the increase in interest rates, investors may end up paying more for the same level of skill (alpha).
If you liked this post, don’t forget to subscribe to Enterprising Investor.
Professional Learning for CFA Institute Members
CFA Institute members can self-determine and self-report professional learning (PL) credits earned, including content on Enterprising Investor. Members can easily record credits using their online PL tracker.
